I am building a work that I cannot finish alone. It is called ATMOSPHERE and can be found at allbut.art. Each participant logs in with an AT Protocol account, watches for 60 seconds a composition produced on their device, and decides whether to share it. The published pieces will then form a larger work.
I did not first design a final form to be divided among participants afterwards. I have built a set of conditions: which public activity enters the calculation, which relationships can be transformed, how long the piece lasts, what can be published and what stays outside. The common work will appear, if it appears, in the accumulation of individual decisions that I do not control.
That uncertainty is not a decorative form of participation. It may produce a gallery that is sparse, repetitive, uncomfortable or at odds with the image I had imagined. It may also reveal a structure that no single piece anticipated. The project accepts that risk.
The account as material, not as a portrait
ATMOSPHERE queries posts, likes, reposts, replies and reactions received, as well as a short stretch of the network’s public stream. It does not use the texts, links, names or dates as content of the work. The browser counts features of participation: volume, distribution of gestures, length, punctuation marks, emojis, capital letters, time slots, bursts and declared language. These magnitudes shape the image, the movement and the sound.
The result does not set out to represent the personality of whoever takes part. Nor does it diagnose mood, ideology or conduct. An account is not a person compressed into a visualisation. It is public activity situated within an infrastructure, with its habits, limits and responses.
The application processes the avatar as a local tone that modifies some parameters, but it neither keeps nor sends the image. Posts are not stored either. The work is generated on the device; sharing it is a later decision.
This separation matters. Personalising is not the same as profiling. The project needs differences so that the forms are not interchangeable, but it does not need to explain who someone is or predict what they will do. Documenting the variables and limiting how they are interpreted helps to maintain that boundary, although it does not settle it for good.
The people who did not press ‘participate’
Among the public data consulted are replies and reactions from other accounts to the posts of whoever takes part. Those people have not entered allbut.art. The project does not keep their identifiers or represent their messages; it only adds aggregated counts to the local calculation.
Caution is still needed. That a piece of data is public does not cancel its status as personal data, and turning it into a figure does not by itself guarantee irreversible anonymisation. That is why I distinguish between the activity consulted, the derived structure and the published piece. The last appears linked to the identifier of whoever decides to share it: it is not anonymous.
This asymmetry is part of the work. A public account is also built from other people’s actions: replies, amplifications, silences, blocks, collective rhythms. The project uses that dimension without appropriating the texts. It does so in a limited and debatable way, not an invisible one.
Sharing changes the status of the piece
The composition is drawn whether or not it is shared. While it stays in the browser, it is a transient appearance. When ‘Share work’ is pressed, the following are published: the image, a derived structure that allows the movement to be reproduced, the date, the public identifier and the link to the profile. A record is also written to the account’s AT Protocol repository.
That record requires a specific permission. OAuth makes it possible to authorise an application without giving it the password, and AT Protocol supports permissions limited by collection and operation. The project requests access to create and delete the type of record it needs, not general authorisation over the account.
The gallery awards no scores and ranks no merits. It has no likes, no rankings and no prize for the most viewed piece. Accumulation should not reproduce the competition of the network from which it draws its material.
Each piece also carries a verifiable signature from the site. The signature certifies that allbut.art published it and that the file has not been replaced without leaving a trace. It does not prove that the piece is original, valuable or legally attributable to a single person. Infrastructure can certify integrity; it does not, by itself, resolve authorship.
A common work without simplified authorship
Calling it a collective work would be convenient, but perhaps premature. I have defined the system, the repertoire of transformations, the duration, the permissions and the form of the gallery. Each participant contributes a configuration derived from their activity and decides whether to publish it. Other accounts intervene indirectly through reactions that they never authorised as an artistic contribution.
Not all those positions carry the same weight or the same intention. ‘Common’ describes the dependence better, for now: no single piece is enough, and the larger work does not exist without contributions from others. It does not automatically make everyone involved a co-author, nor does it allow me to absorb their posts into a general ownership.
The project archive will have to preserve that difference: code, versions, parameters, permissions, generated pieces, withdrawals, the structure of the gallery and curatorial decisions. The guide Documenting the creative process offers the general framework; Preserving a work that depends on a model or an API explains why the infrastructure is also part of what has to be preserved.
The right not to enter and to leave
Taking part does not require sharing. Whoever publishes can delete the record from their repository. To withdraw the copy from the gallery, they must write to me, because the two actions happen in different systems. I will not present that separation as if it were automatic deletion across all copies.
Nor will I keep a piece against the express wishes of the person who shared it. Withdrawal must not become proof of an impossible authorship or an aesthetic negotiation. It is part of the design.
The project page explains what it processes, what it publishes and how to withdraw a piece. The notice on allbut.art contains the applicable legal and technical information.
The element I do not yet explain
There is a perceptual decision that remains undisclosed during this phase. Knowing it could change the behaviour of those who take part and, therefore, the object of the test. It does not alter the data consulted, the permissions requested or the publication. I will document it when the experiment closes.
Withholding a formal element is defensible only if it does not conceal a risk, a processing of data or a legal consequence. That limit is built into the project: surprise may affect how the work is perceived, never the conditions of participation.
ATMOSPHERE may fail. It may fail technically, because the ecosystem and the browsers do not all behave in the same way. It may fail artistically, if the larger work does not sustain a relationship worth preserving. The only way to find out is to let other people enter without promising them in advance what the result will be.
If you take part, you do not complete an image that I already know.
You change the work that does not yet exist.
On the open conversation
If you work with AT Protocol, data protection, preservation or generative art and you spot a problem, you can write to me. This notebook remains open.
The author’s relationship to the case
ATMOSPHERE allbut.art is my own project. I am responsible for its design and for decisions about the gallery. The project contact is hola@juanesteban.art.
